Bay Hill Golf Course Review

50 Words or Less

Arnold Palmer’s Bay Hill Club and Lodge is a challenging, old school layout.  While it’s fun to play a Tour venue, the overall experience falls short of its premium price tag.

Introduction

One hardly needs to be a PGA Tour junkie to be familiar with Bay Hill.  From the tournament’s iconic host to its impressive list of former champions (including Tiger Woods eight times!), this is one of the most famous venues in golf.  But does it deserve to be on your personal bucket list?  Plugged In Golf took a trip to find out.

Practice Facilities

The driving range at Bay Hill is solid if unsurprising.  There’s a lot of space for hitting off grass, and a strip of artificial turf as well.  Pyramids of Callaway golf balls encourage you to hit until you’re happy.  The one exceptionally cool feature is the spot on the end of the range reserved for Mr. Palmer, which you can see above.

When it comes to the short game, Bay Hill has a lot more to offer.  Immediately off the lodge, there’s a large putting green with the mandatory big green Rolex clock.  A short walk from there takes you to an immense short game area where you can practice bunker shots, chips, and pitches into multiple greens.  If you like to practice your short game, you will love this space.

Customer Service & Amenities

In this category, Bay Hill has some high highs and some low lows.  To start with the positives, the pro shop at Bay Hill is pretty great.  I’ll assume that if you’re playing Bay Hill, you’re a fan of Mr. Palmer, and you’ll be quite pleased with the array of hats, shirts, and other umbrellaed gear you can buy.  Also, the clubhouse has fantastic memorabilia – photos, signed guitars, trophies – that fans will love.  Finally, the people who work at Bay Hill were all very friendly and helpful.

On the other side of the coin, there are ways in which Bay Hill feels like its coasting on name recognition and failing to deliver a premium experience.  For one, the carts lack GPS systems.  Bay Hill was the only course on our trip where this was the case.  Also, there was no drinking water on the course.  In Florida’s heat, that’s a pretty big issue.  Finally, the halfway house was closed for the day when we made the turn, compounding the water issue.  With a green fee in the neighborhood of $200, I think it’s reasonable to expect more.

Beauty & Scenery

Bay Hill looks very different during regular play than it does during tournament play.  In fact, it’s kind of jarring.  Due to the grandstands, the houses that surrounds Bay Hill aren’t prominent during the broadcast.  When you play Bay Hill in normal conditions, you realize that they are right on top of the course.  There are some holes where they’re less prominent, but they’re never far away.

The other thing that struck me about Bay Hill is how flat it is.  There is some elevation built into most holes, but the course is largely flat.  Most of the course’s beauty and visual interest centers around the water holes, which are numerous.

Tee Shots

Most of the tee shots at Bay Hill will have you trying to fit your drive in between hazards.  Whether it’s sand or water, there are plenty of obstacles in the fairway to rattle your nerves.  The fairways are narrow to average in width, but they typically get pinched in the prime landing areas – assuming you’re playing the correct tees.  It’s also worth noting that there are a number of slithery fairways, particularly on the shorter holes.  This gives a big advantage to those who know the course and makes the lack of GPS in the carts even more of a downer.

Unless you get out over your skis with tee box selection, Bay Hill is not a course that will beat you up with length.  In fact, our group’s shortest hitter posted the lowest round of the day.  It’s much more important to keep the ball in front of you because there are numerous holes where you can end up in someone’s backyard without hitting a particularly poor drive.  On that note, I’d like to thank a Bay Hill homeowner who was kind enough to come out of her backyard enclose to help me locate a ball in her yard.  It was the closest I’ve ever felt to being a PGA Tour player.

From the right tees, I think the first shots are the most fun part of a round at Bay Hill.  The variety is quite good with a mix of short and long holes and some risk/reward gambles.  For anyone wondering, no, I did not actually take the Bryson line on #6, above.  Purely posing for the ‘gram.

Approaches

While there is a nice variety to the tee shots at Bay Hill, the approach shots are little more monotonous.  The greens are average to slightly below average in size, and each one is guarded by at least two (but often three or four) sand bunkers.  There’s also plenty of water in play, as you can see above.  If you’re not striking your irons well, your score can get ugly in a hurry.

In this category, Bay Hill’s biggest strength is the par 5s.  #16 in particular provides a very exciting risk/reward choice with your second shot.  #6 and #12 aren’t nearly as enticing, but the lack of an easy lay up makes you consider a shot you otherwise wouldn’t.

Greens & Surrounds

To players who are used to the wild contours favored by many modern architects, the greens at Bay Hill will look very mild.  There are no rollercoaster breaks or greens divided into tiers with dramatic elevation changes.  However, that doesn’t mean they lack break or challenge.  Despite their benign appearance, the putting surfaces at Bay Hill yield hardly any straight putts.  If you have the opportunity to take a caddie or lean on a knowledgeable local, do it.

The primary defense around the greens is sand.  While many of the greens are slightly elevated, there aren’t many challenging contours if you miss the putting surface.  When we played, the rough was quite light, so putting through it was a viable option.  If you make smart choices with your approach shot, your short game shouldn’t get too much of a workout at Bay Hill.

Overall Design

As I played Bay Hill, my mind kept slipping back to The Heather at Boyne Highlands [review HERE].  It seems like this design was heavily influenced by the Robert Trent Jones school of design, primarily in its heavily bunkered greens.

Overall, Bay Hill struck me as a course that could yield good scores to strong ball strikers and those with some local knowledge.  A couple trips around the course would shed a lot of light on how to play the shorter par 4s.  That said, it’s a course that’s not afraid to clutter your card with penalty shots.  With significant water hazards on seven holes, you need to make your mistakes at the right times to score well.

Favorite Holes

#2 – Par 3 – 230 Yards

A very beautiful hole, and one of the few where the green is open to something other than a high, accurate approach shot.  This was a favorite for both Dylan and me.

#3 – Par 4 – 435 Yards

This entire hole will be determined by your tee shot.  If you’re tentative (or if you drown your drive), you’re going to have a very tough approach, and you’ll be writing down a big number.  However, if you summon the nerve to hit a strong drive on an aggressive line, you can easily have a wedge into this green.

16 – Par 5 – 510 Yards

Far and away the shortest par 5 at Bay Hill, the water short of the green will test your nerves if you want to try for an eagle.  This would be a fun hole at any point in the round, but having it so late, when a match may be in the balance, makes it even better.

#18 – Par 4 – 460 Yards

The hole itself is fine – a very stout closer – but it earns its spot here because it’s been the backdrop for so many great PGA Tour (read: Tiger Woods) finishes.  The square footage of this green is deceiving because there is no pin location that feels easy.  No matter where they put the cup, you’re only a few paces from a wet landing or a very scary bunker shot.

Conclusion

For the Arnold Palmer fan or the PGA Tour junkie, Bay Hill is a course that definitely needs to be checked off the bucket list.  However, if you’re looking for strong value or a course that the mid-handicapper can succeed at, there are better options in Orlando’s strong golf scene.

Visit the Bay Hill Club HERE

The following two tabs change content below.

Matt Saternus

Founder, Editor In Chief at PluggedInGolf.com
Matt is the Founder and Editor in Chief of Plugged In Golf. He's worked in nearly every job in the golf industry from club fitting to instruction to writing and speaking. Matt lives in the northwest suburbs of Chicago with his wife and two daughters.

Latest posts by Matt Saternus (see all)

5 Comments

  1. I am glad you provided this review, Matt. For a course with its “rep”, Bay Hill appears to be living off of its name. The practice area sounds terrific, but carts with no GPS and the lack of water on the course (not sure if there was a “cart girl”) were Bay Hill’s way of saying to the golfing public …”we know this is on your bucket list, so deal with it”. You are right, there are other options in the greater Orlando area (maybe Meeks can provide some, wink, wink). American golf is booming on many levels now, but courses would be wise to provide value and lasting power in people’s memories. The “boom” won’t last forever even though some people think it will.

    • Matt Saternus

      Steve,

      That’s definitely been my concern in this current boom – making sure that the growth lasts. If courses jack up their rates, stack tee times too close, etc, we’re going to lose golfers as soon as they have other options again.

      Best,

      Matt

      • I don’t really understand why anyone who doesn’t work in the golf industry would want this boom to last. I live in the San Francisco Bay Area, and if I want to play a weekend round at a decent time (able to finish 18) on almost any public course worth playing I have to book at least 2 weeks in advance. Then I need to be prepared for a 5+ hour round, and greens fees that are about 50% higher than I was paying pre-pandemic. I know the industry loves this, as they are making a ton of money, but for us regular golfers who didn’t just start playing last year it absolutely sucks.

  2. Jerry Garbett

    Fabulous venue when watch on TV. The problem I have to expensive for average middle class person like me. I would have to charge the trip and pay interest and that’s not for me. I would love to play the kings course but I will stick to tracks that can afford.

  3. Timothy West

    Thank you for the review Matt. I have not golfed Bay Hill but I have golfed many Orlando area golf courses. I probably will not ever play Bay Hill. If I am going to pay a premium I expected to at least see water out on the course. There are many golfers now and those who remain will remember the places who treated them like a “king”.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

*