Scotty Cameron Phantom X 8 & 8.5 Putter Review

50 Words or Less

The Scotty Cameron Phantom X 8 putter is large, modern mallet.  Two toe hang options plus adjustable weighting.  Feel is much improved from recent Cameron putters.


After a few years of small releases, Scotty Cameron came to the 2019 PGA Show with a massive line of new putters.  In all, there are nine new putters: five different heads, most with two neck options.  In this review, I’ll take a look at the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 8 and Phantom X 8.5.


There’s nothing traditional about the appearance of the Scotty Cameron Phantom X 8 putter.  That starts with the size and continues to the angular, futuristic shape.  At address, the Phantom X 8 and Phantom X 8.5 are the only all black putters in this line; every other  model has some silver.

Cameron refers to the Phantom X 8 as having “continuous alignment.”  Because there is no traditional top line, the milled alignment lines run the length of the putter uninterrupted.  The three dots define the sweet spot.  I prefer a putter without alignment aids, so I was surprised at how much I liked the look of the Phantom X, especially how the lines frame the ball.  The bright yellow paint will likely be a turn off to some, but it does provide sharp contrast.

Sound & Feel

In my opinion, the Phantom X putters have the best feel of any Scotty Cameron in quite a while.  The face and flange are one solid piece of milled 6061 aluminum.  This gives the putter a firm, solid feel on impact.

As you would expect from a mallet, small mishits are hard to feel.  Large mishits can be sensed in the hands, but you have to make an aggressively bad stroke to get this putter head to twist.


There is one key difference between the Phantom X 8 and the Phanton X 8.5: toe hang.  The Phantom X 8 is face-balanced.  Mr. Cameron goes overboard in referring to this as “Mid-Bend Shaft Technology,” but, marketing aside, this configuration is designed for the player with minimal face rotation in their stroke.

The Phantom X 8.5 has “Low-Bend Shaft Technology” which creates a slight toe hang.  This allows players with arcing strokes to take advantage of the performance benefits of a mallet.

The two major performance benefits of the Phantom X 8 are alignment and forgiveness.  I felt immediately comfortable aiming the Phantom X 8, and my results on short and medium range putts were excellent.  Additionally, these putters have the forgiveness you would expect from a modern mallet.  As long as you keep the ball near the center of the face, it will get to the hole on its intended line.

Finally, both Phantom X 8 models feature adjustable weight ports in the sole near the face.  Golfers can plug in weights of 10, 15, or 20 grams to customize the head weight to fit their swing weight preference.


The Phantom X putters are a stark departure from Scotty Cameron’s normal flow of traditional head styles.  With the Phantom X 8 and Phantom X 8.5, he offers an interesting, futuristic shape with bold alignment help and a variety of ways to customize the performance.

Matt Saternus
Latest posts by Matt Saternus (see all)


  1. william Neal

    It doesn’t look all that futuristic. Not gonna rush out to try it. No mention of suggested retail price.

  2. I wouldn’t even be able to look at it, and I’m a mallet guy, a beat up old original GoLo Select, now wearing its fifth pistolino, lol.

  3. Looks like they haven’t done anything to the face to make the ball role better technology wise

  4. Ross Baker

    “It has to be a very bad mishit for the head to twist!” Was this based on ‘photo’s’ or feel? Because it’s widely accepted now, that ‘face balancing’ doesn’t prevent head twist! And in fact has little to do with ‘straighter putts’ or ‘putts holed’!

    • Matt Saternus


      The line you paraphrase is from the “Sound & Feel” section, so you can assume it refers to the way the club feels.
      Who said anything about toe hang/face balancing relating to head twisting? This head doesn’t twist on mishits because it has high MOI.


  5. Being a mallet guy playing now fangs style from Oddyssey (Nr. 7) and being happy with it, this is first Scotty which I am tempted to look at. These two paralel aiming lines are great and similar to fangs style. Years I played with one long line or three lines, but for me 2 lines like this is the best by far. i recommend trying to any mallet guy to give it a try, if you never had this 2 lines aiming aid.

  6. Hector Fernandez

    Waiting for Mr. Cameron to get back to making real putters. Until then Mr. Cameron! BTW, I still use a Custom 009 Mr. Cameron made for me about ten years ago. No need for gimmicks, just putters!

  7. I have a Newport 2 and it’s a classic that I love. That said I think these are outstanding putters with lots of choices for different strokes. I like the simple look of the #8.

  8. Terence James Graham

    I have a Red X (original & mark II) mallet putters, plus a GoLo #8 mallet putter. I am interested in a Phantom #8.5 mallet putter as well now provided the current price is right.

  9. I’ve just put the 8.5 in the bag from a Newport 2. This putter is excellent. The feel is amazing, and the alignment lines really frame the ball well. I tend to struggle with alignment, and this system works well for me. I didn’t expect to like this putter, but I’m really enjoying it.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *