Are All Zero Torque Putters the Same?
Zero torque putters have been all the rage in golf for the last two years, but are all zero torque putters made equal? Before we can answer that question, we’re faced with another one: what’s the purest way to compare putters?
For this Golf Myths Unplugged, we decided to test six of the best zero torque putters head-to-head…literally. We’ve kept all the other variables the same to isolate the head and find the best performing zero torque putter.
The Categories
Best Roll
Most Forgiving
Most Consistent
Best at Short Range
Best at Mid Range
Best at Long Range
How We Tested
For this test, we compared six zero torque putters: the LAB Golf DF3 [review HERE], TaylorMade Spider ZT [review HERE], Bettinardi Antidote SB2, Odyssey Ai-ONE Square 2 Square Max 1, Macro Golf Square Stroke Mallet, and the PXG Allan [review HERE].
Our focus was to build all putters for consistency. We took all six putters in this test and built them with the Macro Golf SquareStroke Shaft-Handle [more info HERE]. This is a one-piece 100% carbon shaft/handle that weighs approximately 105 grams and uses an oval-elliptical, wrist-locking shape. The goal of the SquareStroke Shaft-Handle is to reduce unwanted hand and wrist movement during the stroke, giving us a common shaft and handle platform across every putter in the test.
This testing was conducted in three stages. First, we tested all six putters on SAM Puttlab, measuring every stroke. Second, we tested the putters on a Foresight GCQuad. Finally, we tested the putters on short (5′), medium (15′), and long range (30′) putts on an outdoor putting green. The testing was done by three different groups of eight golfers with handicaps ranging from scratch to fifteen.
SAM Puttlab testing was done at and with the help of Club Champion.
Results
A couple notes before we get into the winners and losers. First, as we have seen consistently across 13+ years of Golf Myths Unplugged testing, the results vary meaningfully from player to player. In any given category, a putter that was the worst overall might have been the best for a particular golfer. The other key note that’s specific to this test is that all of these putters are quite good. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend any of these putters, if well fit.
Best Roll
We used the Foresight data to determine the putter with the best roll, looking at a combination of Skid Length and Time to Full Roll. These two factors split our putter group in half, with superior performance coming from the Odyssey, Bettinardi, and LAB Golf putters. The Macro, PXG, and TaylorMade putters had average skid lengths of over 21″. With the other three putters, the skid distance was between 17″ and 18″.
Of the top three, the Bettinardi was in a clear third place. Between the top two we were splitting hairs, but the Odyssey Ai-ONE Square 2 Square Max 1 got to true roll, on average, about 0.25″ faster than the LAB Golf DF3.
Most Forgiving
For this, we again used Foresight data to keep things clear and objective, looking at the smash factor range of each putter. Across a dozen putts per player, each putter had the chance to show its ability to keep ball speed consistent across the face.
All of the putters did very well in this category. The difference between the best and worst putter was 0.06, telling us that every putter did a good job keeping ball speed consistent. That said, the winner was the LAB Golf DF3, followed closely by the TaylorMade Spider ZT. The PXG Allan and Macro Mallet were a small step behind, and the Bettinardi and Odyssey were closely bunched at the still-impressive rear of this group.
Most Consistent
To judge the most consistent putter, we used data from SAM PuttLab. This system produces two scores – Rotational Consistency and Overall Consistency – that we used to select a winner. These numbers reflect how consistently the putter is swung – path, tempo, rotation, and impact location – not necessarily how “good” the stroke is or what the real world results are.
Actually, we used the data to select two winners: the Bettinardi Antidote SB2 and the Macro Mallet. They finished 1-2 in both categories with Bettinardi winning Rotational Consistency and Macro winning Overall Consistency. The PXG Allan finished in third. Interestingly, the LAB Golf DF3 finished in last despite winning or contending in every other category.
The final three awards came from our outdoor testing. Each player hit five putts from each distance with each putter. We counted made putts and measured the total distance left on the misses.
Best at Short Range
At short range, the TaylorMade Spider ZT came out on top. Our testers averaged over 3.5 made putts and left themselves just a few inches from the cup when all their misses were added up.
In a close second was the LAB Golf DF3. The test group averaged just over 3 made putts. Third through sixth were the Macro Mallet, Bettinardi, Odyssey, and PXG. The gap in this testing was note huge – all of the putters made their share and left their misses inside eighteen inches.
Best at Mid Range
Moving back ten feet allowed the PXG Allan to shine. At 15′, the PXG Allan and LAB Golf DF3 made an equal number of putts and left virtually every miss within tap-in range. The PXG Allan did edge out the DF3 with slightly shorter leaves, taking the mid range title.
The TaylorMade Spider ZT, so strong at short range, struggled at mid-range with the fewest made putts and longest leaves. Spots three through five went to Odyssey, Bettinardi, and Macro, respectively.
Best at Long Range
PXG and LAB Golf continued to shine on the longest putts, again finishing 1-2. There weren’t many putts made at this range, as you would expect, but PXG and LAB Golf tied again. At this range, however, the DF3 took the crown with the shortest leaves. This is a real-world reflection of the DF3’s outstanding forgiveness.
Macro and Odyssey were the middle of the pack at 30 feet, making a small handful of putts. TaylorMade and Bettinardi rounded out the test group with only a couple makes and some substantial leaves.
Takeaways
After hundreds of putts, two things stand out. First, all of these putters are excellent, so it’s key to find the one that’s best for you. The putters that were lower in our ranking were still the best for certain players.
The second thing that must be said is how impressive the LAB Golf DF3 is. With one exception, it was top two in every category. From short putts to long putts, forgiveness to roll, this is one of the best performing putters in golf.
He founded Plugged In Golf in 2013 with the goal of helping all golfers play better and enjoy the game more.
Matt lives in the northwest suburbs of Chicago with his wife and two daughters.
- The Five Levels of Club Fitting - August 10, 2026
- BGT Silo Tour Wedge Shaft Review - August 7, 2026
- Odyssey Ai-ONE Square 2 Square Max 1 Putter Review - August 4, 2026
26 Comments
Hi Matt,
I appreciate the write-up and the side by side comparisons. It’s helpful to see everything in one place.
I have an odd request: Any chance you could do a “Best ZT under $300” comparison or something similar? I know there are a lot of offerings in that space, and it would be helpful for people (like me) who are on a budget and can’t necessarily spend on “the best” but certainly make an upgrade.
While I read you used the same grip on all the putters tested – somewhat related: Do you think there are or should be specific grips made for ZT putters. I’m asking because I recall a recent interview you had with L.A>B where they (he) recommended keeping thumbs of/ or at least on the sides of the grip when using ZT putters.
I’m currently using a Wilson Lakeview and the first thing I did was to change out the grip to a SS pistol grip. While better than Wilson’s grip, it’s still not perfect .
Tony,
Great question. I think the “Press” grips that neutralize the forward shaft lean of some ZT designs make a lot of sense. However even that is personal. I don’t think there’s a universal “best grip” or even best category of grips for all ZT putters.
I’ve found a lot of success with Sam Hahn’s advice about taking the thumbs off, and that leads me toward slightly larger grips with ZT putters.
Best,
Matt
What lie angle are these set to? Lie angle is personal, and affects multiple factors when putting.
Dave,
Every putter was left at the stock lie angle.
-Matt
Any reason no blade ZT weren’t included in this test?
Chuck,
Our goal was to compare the highest performing ZT mallets. If there’s interest, we can do another test of ZT blades.
Best,
Matt
Matt, for what it’s worth, this (i.e., ZT blade test) would absolutely be of high interest to me.
Good morning I’m surprised that you didn’t include the Lazrus LAZ2.5 ZT putter in your testing !!
We focused on the best selling and highest performing ZT putters. It would have been nice to include every ZT putter under the sun, but for the amount of testing we did, that was not practical.
I’ll add that we have been in contact with Lazrus previously, and, at least at that time, they were not interested in an independent review.
-Matt
Any particular reason there were no Evnroll ZT putters tested?
We focused on the best selling and highest performing ZT putters. It would have been nice to include every ZT putter under the sun, but for the amount of testing we did, that was not practical.
-Matt
Why no Lazurus putters
We focused on the best selling and highest performing ZT putters. It would have been nice to include every ZT putter under the sun, but for the amount of testing we did, that was not practical.
I’ll add that we have been in contact with Lazrus previously, and, at least at that time, they were not interested in an independent review.
-Matt
I hv been using the PXG Mustang II ZT putter for over a year. Simply put it works. Short, mid, long range it is excellent. Confidence level has improved, especially, on mid and long range. It is not a “soft” but rather a firm feeling putter. More of a traditional shape.
I have had the Antidote SB2, I have tried many different ZT putters and none have been able to push it out of the bag yet. I bought it slightly used so I got a good price on it. It is amazing how many new putters end up in the used putter section at PGATSS not long after they are released.
Although I’ve just banished a Zero Tork putter from my bag (didn’t work for me at all 🤷🏽) and regretfully returned to my good old Ray Cook M1-G3 mallet putter, I’m still very interested in the Macro Golf SquareStroke Shaft-Handle.
Unfortunately, the manufacturer’s website isn’t responding, and I can’t find any other sources about it online either.
Do you have any more information?
Sincerely,
Joachim.
Joachim,
What information are you looking for?
We are considering a full review of the Shaft-Handle, if there’s reader interest for it.
Best,
Matt
All infos I can get – a full review would be a good start ! 😉
But what concerns me is that the manufacturer‘s homepage isn‘t available – does he still exist, or is he gone out of business ?
Sincerely,
Joachim.
Joachim,
I just clicked the link in the article – https://www.macrogolf.com/squarestroketechnology/ – and it worked for me.
Macro Golf definitely still exists. They’re just getting started, really.
Best,
Matt
It’s working for me now, too, thanks. It wasn’t working for hours this morning (and just this homepage ! ) – probably because someone was „standing on the internet cable“ somewhere…! 😉
Anyway, I’m still interested in a thorough test – when do you think I can realistically expect that to happen?
Sincerely,
Joachim.
Joachim,
It’s hard to say as we always have a lot of balls in the air. I would guess the earliest would be early September.
Best,
Matt
Hi, Matt,
I just took another close look at the photos and have to admit, I’m a little confused: Could it be that – at least in the photos – the wider (“thicker”) side of the grip is facing the flag, just like the clubface, and the narrow side is pointing away from the flag? That seems very uncomfortable and unergonomic to me!
It seems much better to me if the wider (“thicker”) side of the grip faces my body and the narrow side faces away from me! That way, the grip sits perfectly and securely in my left hand and can be firmly supported by my right hand, especially with my thumb!
Maybe you could try that out during your tests as well…?
I’d really appreciate it!
Sincerely,
Joachim.
Joachim,
The widest portion of the grip is perpendicular to the club face.
Best,
Matt
Hi Matt !
I just tried to order a Square Stroke Putter Grip, paying by PayPal.
I was told that the item cannot be shipped to my address in Germany.
Very disappointing – I’d really like to test the grip!
Sincerely,
Joachim.
P. S.:
I haven’t received a reply to my email inquiry to Macrogolf either.
I don’t consider that to be professional business conduct, sorry ! 🤷🏽
I can hardly wait! 😉👍