Time for Something Weird…
After nearly eight years of busting myths, we feel like we’ve taken on most of the obvious ones. Some of the best ones we’ve even done twice. This time around, we decided to take on something a little more unusual – jumbo club grips.
While jumbo grips have become de rigueur in putters, they haven’t caught on with drivers and irons. Are regular golfers missing out? Is Bryson ahead of the curve again? We did this test to find out.
The Myths
Myth #1 – Bigger grips create more club head speed
Myth #2 – Bigger grips create more distance
Myth #3 – Bigger grips are more accurate
Myth #4 – Bigger grips work best with longer shafts
Myth #5 – Bigger grips are more consistent
How We Tested
For this test, we brought together five golfers with handicaps between 0 and 14. Each player hit five drives each with four drivers. Two drivers were 45″, two were 47″. At each length, one driver had a standard grip, one has a Jumbo Max grip. All players used the exact same driver head and the same driver shafts – a Mitsubishi Diamana TB [review HERE]. All testers were required to wait at least one minute between swings to more closely simulate on course conditions. All shots were recorded on Trackman.
All testing was done at and with the help of Club Champion.
Special thanks to Mitsubishi for providing the Diamana TB shafts for this test.
The Results
In our very first myth, we find a very interesting result. With the 45″ driver, there was not a clear winner. Three testers gained club head speed with the bigger grip, but the maximum gain was 0.9 MPH. The two who lost speed each lost over 1 MPH. On average, the group lost 0.12 MPH with the big grip. However, when we switched to the 47″ driver, four out of five testers gained speed and the gains were bigger. On average, the bigger grip helped our testers swing the longer driver 0.88 MPH faster.
On balance, I’m rating this plausible because of the consistent gains at 47″. The only tester who didn’t gain club head speed with the bigger grip and longer shaft was rather small, physically. This leads me to suggest that larger golfers have the potential to gain speed with a bigger grip, but smaller golfers may not.
While the bigger grip did help most of our testers create more club head speed, that did not regularly translate into more distance. With the 45″ driver, two of our testers gained distance with the big grip – 2.5 and 2.9 yards, respectively. However, the other three testers lost 3.9, 13.8, and 11.9 yards. The picture was equally grim with the longer driver. Only one tester gained distance – 5.9 yards – and the other four lost an average of 5.5 yards.
This makes sense in light of the testers’ comments about the big grip. While none of the testers complained about the longer shaft, the majority stated that the bigger grip felt unusual. The result was lower smash factor, less ball speed, and less distance.
The accuracy picture is very muddled. Out of the ten test pairs, the bigger grip produced a superior average offline number six times. This means that, on average, shots with the bigger grip were closer to the center line. The group average with bigger grips was 2.4 yards better.
When we look at left-to-right dispersion, however, the results flipped. Out of the ten test pairs, the regular grip was better seven times. On average, the dispersion with the smaller grip with 9.7 yards smaller.
Looking at the shot distributions, the bigger grips was feast-or-famine. It produced a lot of shots near the centerline but also numerous foul balls. The standard grip was more consistent. This myth is busted.
This myth is a pure nod to Bryson, he of the Jumbo Max grip and 48″ driver. While our first myth did reveal that the long shaft + big grip combo did create more club head speed, that speed did not convert into distance. Additionally, the accuracy stats were equally muddy with the long and short shafts. Thus, we have no reason to believe that big grips are a better fit with longer shafts.
It should come as no surprise that this myth is busted, too. We’ve already discussed that bigger grips led to poorer ball striking and more erratic ball speed. We also noted that, with regards to accuracy, the bigger grips were hit and miss. We did specifically examine consistency of carry distance and found that the big grips were no better or worse than standard grips.
If you are looking for a magical cure for inconsistency, it does not appear that bigger grips are it.
The Takeaway
While massive club grips seem to be working quite well for Bryson DeChambeau, it does not appear that they’re a miracle cure for the average golfer. That said, the grip – even an extreme one – should be considered in every club fitting. And if you like the feel of a giant grip, there’s no reason not to give it a try. With more time to acclimate to it, it’s possible that there are benefits to be unlocked, just don’t expect an overnight change to your game.
Matt lives in the northwest suburbs of Chicago with his wife and two daughters.
- OnCore Elixr 2022 Golf Ball Review - December 7, 2023
- Titleist U505 Utility Iron Review - December 6, 2023
- Podcast Episode 205 – Learning Golf from Chess - December 6, 2023
I have small hands and due to swing changes, for the better I hope, found now my misses were to the left and the dreaded hook would even show it’s ugly head ever so often. I fought with the left misses for a year. Then read some info., concerning club fitting and grips. Changed my driver to MCC +4 Midsize first. I did find after a week of getting used to the new size, that I was finding the fairway considerably more often. So changed out the whole set and am in love. Going up a size has been a plus for me. Is it for everyone? Probably not, but my accuracy has improved and I like the feel.
Those larger heftier grips changed your swing weight and that was the change you needed.
Tough and test here, there’s obviously a learning curve and more importantly a comfort level associated with these larger grips that may have skewed the data don’t you think?
Michael,
That’s an issue with every test and fitting. We’d love to give people a couple weeks to get acclimated to the big grip, but then you’re adding in the variable of time between samples. We try to approach this like a fitting where you take a handful of swings and if the results aren’t better, you move on.
-Matt
I’ve been using MCC+4 Midsize for about 5 years now and it has really helped me keep a more relaxed grip and has done wonders to limit the dreaded snap hook.
Same here with my driver, Adam. I have medium sized hands and always used standard grips on all clubs, but noticed a gap between my thumb and forefinger on the driver grip that was creating club face variability. (Right handed golfer). The Standard +4 grip added more thickness on the bottom right hand and my grip is more secure and relaxed.
Hi
I just changed my grips from Midsize to Standard size, I get more feeling and more relaxed in the hands.
I’m tall and I have also tried Jumbo grips.
I went from regular midsize to using midsize less tapered grips 5 months ago. . I saw some immediate improvement to my right miss and am still seeing some more improvement as time goes by. I am 65, small hands but standard thin grips hurt my hands as the round goes along. The mid size helps that also. And I do fell I gained 5 yards a club with the Less Tapered grip.
What was the change in swing weight when using the larger (and heavier?) grip?
Your bigger grip, longer shaft test probably created a club with similar swing weight as testers normal club… so they were used to it.
Bigger grip and 45” shaft is shorter than most manufacturers standard nowadays (45.5”) and with the heavier grip you created a really low swing weight which your tester probably didn’t like because they lost feeling of the club head.
Just yesterday, I tried a 45” HZRDS Smoke Black RDX with a midsized MCC plus 4 (66g vs 57g standard) and immediately picked up 10-20 yards of carry.
No TrackMan, but spin was probably up too as peak height and hang time increased.
No myths busted, but I’ll be playing with the shaft grip combo today, so we’ll see how it goes.
Dimark,
I don’t remember exactly offhand, but my recollection is that the larger grip made the SW something like 6-8 points lighter.
-Matt
Lemme get one of those Diamana TB big fella. Let’s party Matt.
Big grip helps single plane swingers like Bryson and Moe Norman. Takes the hands right out of the swing, all arms.
You didn’t say what size JumboMax grip you used…they come in 5 sizes. Bryson uses the XL size.
JumboMax says on their website that golfers with medium to large golf glove size should use a medium sized grip.
Also, the latest JumboMax grips are the same or lighter than regular grips.
I switched because of severe arthritis in my fingers. The lighter grip I’m able to now take means straighter more consistent shots.
Distance about the same.
I just put a midsized grip on my driver with 6 or 7 wraps on the bottom with the theory of letting me have a go but minimizing my miss left hook.The feel is nice on lower hand with my right elbow feeli g more flexed at address.Any thoughts
If it’s working for you, it sounds good to me.
Best,
Matt
I have had Jumbo Max grips (XL) on my driver, 7 wood, & hybrids (3 & 4) in 2020. Love them. I added them to my irons in 2021 & it hasn’t worked out. I have struggled & seem to have lost swing speed & distance with the XL grips. I have been struggling with my irons. I think am going back to CP-2 on my irons soon.
I have been using jumbo grips on all my clubs for a number of years now. The main reason was arthritis but I do like the feel of bigger grips because I feel like I can go after it with more confidence.
Im a mid handicap that have been using standard grips since forever. 5’8″ 160lbs. I use a med glove. So I don’t have huge hands nor small.
I changed to jumbomax grips in the XS ( still quite bigger than standard).1/8 I think.
I gain 15-20yard on my irons.
10-15yrd on woods and driver, with a significant accuracy/consistency.
I use to hit my 7 150-155yrd and now hitting it 170.
Im not sure what really cause this increase because it only increase my club head speed by 2-3mph.
Regardless, im sold on bigger grips. Ill never go back.
Jumbomax has the Ultralight grip which is only 47 grams for the their midsize grip, so swing weight is not affected using this version of the grip.
Hi Team, I wear a double extra large glove and went to a jumbo grip as Bryson started to get results. Because I was in regular grip, that I now know didn’t fit, the move to a bigger grip has been priceless but I put that to being in the right grip now for me.
I found your test very interesting as I have had many of the same questions. I am 76 and a 16 handicap with the usual arthritis. I have had driver woes for two years now. Recently I put a Golf Pride cp2 jumbo size grip on an old Cleveland 270 driver for a test. After two rounds , I never had a driver miss hit. I hit the shots straighter and 8-10 yards longer. I acquired a slight fad in my shot. The grip is so much better in comfort with less grip pressure.