Can AI Replace Club Fitters?

We independently review everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
AI Fitter vs Humans

Man vs. Machine

Earlier this year, we detailed how Club Champion is leaning heavily into artificial intelligence with their proprietary AI Co-Pilot system [learn more HERE].  Recently I got to watch this system in action to see how it’s helping golfers and whether it has the potential to replace fitters completely.

Can AI Replace Club Fitters? review

The Fitting

This was a fun fitting for me to watch, as it was one of my friends fitting another.  The fitter was none other than Drew Koch, who, in addition to being a Plugged In Golf staff writer, is a master club fitter with Club Champion.  The golfer was Alex.  Alex is 51, a very solid player, looking for a driver to replace his eight year old PING G400.  He came in viewing his driving as “consistent” and reliable, but not a “big strength.”

The fitting started with Alex making ten swings with his current gamer, and and Drew talking Alex through what he was seeing in the numbers..  Then all of the Trackman data was fed into AI Co-Pilot, and the system generated five shaft recommendations.  What was most interesting about this list was the range of options: everything from a 60 gram stiff flex to a 40 gram senior flex.

Shaft testing started with a very popular option, the Fujikura Ventus Blue 5-S [review HERE].  It didn’t take more than a couple swings for Drew to see that this was a poor fit for Alex’s smooth transition.  The data from the few Ventus Blue swings were fed into AI Co-Pilot, the recommendations changed slightly, but Drew went off script and pulled the Fujikura Ventus White in 4-R [review HERE].  While not one of AI Co-Pilot’s recommendations, it was in line with the smooth, 40 gram option the system suggested.

Can AI Replace Club Fitters? review

The results with the Ventus White were excellent.  Club and ball speed went up, and smash factor crossed the 1.5 threshold several times.  In the interest of being thorough, Drew fed this data into AI Co-Pilot.  The system generated more new ideas, though it did start to hone in on Alex’s preference for something a bit lighter and softer.  A couple more shafts were tested, but nothing outperformed Ventus White.

PING G440 LST Driver

With the shaft choice locked in, Drew asked AI Co-Pilot which head would be a good fit.  The system returned two options: the PING G440 LST [review HERE] that Alex was already using to test shafts and the Titleist GTS2 [review HERE].  While both options performed well, there was little question that the PING was the better option for Alex.

Can AI Replace Club Fitters? review

The Final Results

Alex’s gains were impressive.  He picked up roughly 8 MPH of ball speed, over 7 yards of carry, and over 18 yards total.  All that while painting the center line.  Club fitting makes a huge difference.

Can AI Replace Club Fitters? review

The Case for AI Club Fitting

There’s no doubt that AI Co-Pilot brings something to the table.  After watching it in action with my techno optimist hat on, here are the things that stood out.

The Range of Solutions

Any given fitter is going to watch a player and start thinking about the solution.  AI Co-Pilot, with well over 50,000,000 data points in its system, shows the range of possible solutions.  It’s simultaneously narrowing the field and keeping options open.

No Ruts

Unlike human fitters, AI isn’t going to get stuck in a rut of solving the same problem the same way every time.  While there’s nothing wrong with the same old solution, there may be better ones.  With access to every fit from every fitter, AI is constantly finding the newest, best solution to a given problem.

Speed & Precision

While AI Co-Pilot started with a wide net during the shaft fitting, once it had enough data, it was able to speed us toward the final answer with the club head.  Toward the end of the fitting, Alex noted that he was getting tired.  Having to only test two driver heads was extremely helpful in making the fitting efficient.

Can AI Replace Club Fitters? review

The Case Against AI Club Fitting

Give me a moment to walk across the aisle, and I’ll tell you why AI club fitting is not the panacea it claims to be.  On this side, I’m imagining the fitting that happened without any human involvement.

Just the Data

Every good fitting starts with a conversation.  In an AI fitting, we don’t have a conversation, we just have ten shots and a bunch of numbers.  The AI doesn’t understand who the golfer is as a player, what they’re trying to achieve, what brands they love, what sound they hate, or any of the other nuances that separate an adequate fit from a really great, personal one.

Too Many Swings

Earlier I noted that AI can help save swings in a fitting, but it can also waste them.  The AI can’t pull the plug on a bad combination the way a human fitter can.  It sees one bad swing as just one data point, where an experienced human fitter sees a golfer fighting a shaft that’s never going to work.  Multiply three or four wasted swings over two or four or six “bad” combinations, and you have a very tired golfer.

Human Experience & Intuition

In the fitting I watched, the best combination didn’t come directly from AI Co-Pilot’s list of suggestions.  There was a similar shaft on the initial list, and the final choice may have appeared given more time, but Drew was able to get to it faster because of his experience and knowledge of Alex’s swing.

Can AI Replace Club Fitters? review

The Best of Both Worlds

I’m sure that at one point, some people worried that launch monitors would replace club fitters.  Same with interchangeable heads and shafts.  Neither did, and AI won’t either.  All of these things are tools that a skilled club fitter can use to deliver a better fit for the golfer.

If you want the best fitting, you want the best human fitter using the best technology.  That means the best launch monitors, the most hittable combinations, and the smartest AI.  You can find all of those at Club Champion.

Matt Saternus
Connect
Latest posts by Matt Saternus (see all)

Join the Conversation | 2 Comments

  1. AI is still new in so many areas. Some day I think it can replace a human, how far down the road who knows. That’s an issue for me, I like human interaction. I’m good with AI if it helps me get the best fit. Right now nothing can beat a good human fitter. AI is in use in designing better golf equipment now also. Love your outlook and articles, especially your equipment reviews. I start everyday with plugged in golf.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

 

Plugged In Golf's Mission Is Made Possible With Support From:


Recent Reviews